User:ScottHudson/Fictional American Idol 3: Face-Off

Season 1

 * Kelly Clarkson
 * Justin Guarini
 * Nikki McKibbin

Season 2

 * Ruben Studdard
 * Clay Aiken
 * Kimberley Locke

Season 3

 * Fantasia
 * Diana DeGarmo
 * Jasmine Trias

Season 4

 * Carrie Underwood
 * Bo Bice
 * Vonzell Solomon

Season 5

 * Taylor Hicks
 * Katherine McPhee
 * Elliot Yamin

Season 6

 * Jordin Sparks
 * Blake Lewis
 * Melinda Doolittle

Season 7

 * David Cook
 * David Archuleta
 * Syesha Mercado

Season 8

 * Kris Allen
 * Adam Lambert
 * Danny Gokey

Season 9

 * Lee DeWyze
 * Crystal Bowersox
 * Casey James

Season 1
Due to two top three's, because of a returning contestant, there are four people in this group.
 * David Archuleta
 * Scott Hudson
 * Vanessa Hudgens (first top 3)
 * Chris Daughtry (second top 3)